The Park Savoy, like all historic
buildings, has had many lives and has even more stories to tell.
Over a hundred years ago, it was home to an early Florham Park
family. In fact, at the very heart of the present-day building, the
bones of that 1870 house still exist. It was built in the Second
Empire style fashionable at the time and the style’s characteristic
mansard
roof is visible today in the building's roofline. The house and the
surrounding 150 acre dairy farm formed the homestead of George W.
Felch (1822-1899), the patriarch of
a prominent early family of
Columbia, as Florham Park was known during the 19th century. Felch was instrumental in the early planning and fund
raising which led to the building of the town’s Little Red School
House just down the road at the corner of Ridgedale and Columbia
Turnpike. His son, George E. Felch, served as the town’s second
mayor from 1902-1906 and was a key member of both the Board of
Education and the fire department, helping to insure the importance
of the Felch name in Florham Park history.
In 1918, nearly twenty years after his
father died, George E. Felch sold the house and much of the property
to Edwin S. Marston, a New York financier and the president of the
Farmers Loan and Trust Company. The Marston’s remodeled and enlarged
the house, transforming it into a showcase, described the Madison
Eagle of May 11, 1923 as “pretentious.” As
the Eagle reported, “[the house] measuring ninety-six feet by thirty
feet, has gas, electric lights, steam heat and running water…four
masters’ bedrooms, three tiled bathrooms. Outside, it boasted a
“fully enclosed tennis court, rose garden, garage for two cars, with
an adjoining shed suitable for four cars, and a large laundry.
The Marston era was short-lived however.
Edwin Marston died suddenly at age seventy-one in October of 1922.
By the following May, his wife Emma had decided to sell the property
to Samuel “Schimmy” Blume and Jacob Weinberg of Newark. According to
the Madison Eagle article mentioned above, they planned to use it as an “inn and dancing
resort.” With this sale, a new and very different era in the house’s
history began.
The 18th Amendment to the
Constitution prohibiting the sale of alcoholic beverages across the
United States was ratified in 1919. As a result, prohibition, and
the illegal activities to circumvent it, were well underway when Blume and Weinberg purchased the Marston property. They immediately
remodeled the house and opened it as a speakeasy, taking over the
name and the clientele of another Florham Park nightclub known as
Canary Cottage which had just burned to the ground at the end of
March, 1923. In 1924, Blume and Weinburg enhanced the venue by
adding a nine hole golf course on the grounds.
The Canary Cottage soon became associated
with a string of nightclubs operated by a New Jersey crime
syndicate. Key figure in the syndicate included “Lucky” Luciano,
“Longy” Zwillman and
Willie Moretti. Known as the “Al Capone of New
Jersey,” Zwillman was a founding member of the National Crime
Syndicate and was also romantically involved for a time with the actress Jean Harlow. As Zwillman reportedly said to his
partners, “We open good-looking joints…no riffraff. We get the most
prominent citizens from the big city and the suburbs and we make ‘em
feel comfortable.’ During this period, the Canary Cottage was
renamed The Carriage Club and it attracted the wealthy and the
powerful, including Charles Lindbergh and Charles Edison, the son of
Thomas Edison.
When prohibition was repealed in 1933,
Schimmy Blume changed the name of his establishment back to Canary
Cottage and painted the building bright canary yellow. For the next
twenty years, the
nightclub continued to attract clientele from all
over North Jersey for dancing and cocktails. It was known as the
Blue Elms Country Club for a brief period of time before it became
the semi-private Florham Park Country Club in 1959 which
remained in operation until 1981.
In 1982, the current owner, Alan Weinstein, purchased the property and renamed it The Park Savoy. Originally opened as a restaurant and dance club. In 1993, Mr. Weinstein began a restoration process that has restored the elegance and grandeur of this 19th century landmark.
The Park Savoy is now a completely restored historic mansion used exclusively for hosting one wedding at a time. The fireplaces, original antique furnishings and the exquisite bridal
suite create an atmosphere that is warm and intimate. Floor to ceiling windows, beautiful vistas, and formal gardens provide a spectacular setting for outdoor wedding ceremonies and cocktail receptions. The Park Savoy fulfills Lucky Luciano and Longy Zwillman's desire to create a venue where "the most prominent citizens from the big city and the suburbs would come and we make 'em feel comfortable."